Bedford, Indiana · Since 1945 · Lawrence County's First Pizzeria

Same sauce.
81 years running.

Charlie Grecco came back from New York with a recipe. Nobody's touched it since. That's the pizza you're getting.

4.2 ★ 482 Reviews #1 Pizza in Bedford Dine-in · Carryout · Delivery
This Week's Deals

Something good every day of the week

Mon
Spaghetti SpecialMeat sauce + garlic bread + tossed salad
$8.99
Tue
$1 Off Any Whole SandwichAll stromboli-style sandwiches included
$1 off
Wed
Large 2-Topping PizzaHand-tossed. No substitutions.
$10.99
Thu
XL 2-Topping + Family BreadsticksFamily breadsticks = 8 sticks
$19.99
Build Your Order

See it before you call.

Pick your size, crust, sauce, and toppings. The price updates as you build. Then call us or order on Grubhub.

$11.79 Medium · Hand-Tossed · Original Sauce
Size
Personal$3.29
Small$9.39
Medium$11.79
Large$14.49
XL$17.09
Big Boy$19.39
Crust
Hand-Tossed
Thin Crust
Deep Dish
Sauce
Original
BBQ
Garlic Butter
Hot Sauce
Toppings (tap to add)
Pepperoni
Sausage
Ham
Bacon
Ground Beef
Mushroom
Onion
Green Pepper
Black Olive
Banana Pepper
Jalapeño
Pineapple
Medium hand-tossed · Original sauce · No toppings yet

Charlie came back from New York
with a recipe.

In 1945, Charlie and Frances Grecco opened a small place at 519 Lincoln Avenue in Bedford. They served plate lunches, spaghetti, salads. Then Charlie heard about pizza. He went to New York City, found his Italian relatives, and came back with a sauce recipe that nobody has changed since.

"Consistency and quality control is why we've stayed in business so long."
— Jaclyn Sabatier, third generation

That was 81 years ago. Grecco's has had three owners in all that time. Frank Wenzel bought it in 1975. Dave Sabatier bought it in 1990. His daughter Jaclyn grew up in this kitchen — she started washing dishes at 9. The dining room still has the original 1970s wood paneling. The red booths are the same. The recipe hasn't moved an inch.

The building is shaped like a pizza slice. That wasn't an accident. Bedford knows that building. You probably already know it.

Find Us

Hours & Location

Hours
Mon – Thu11:00 AM – 10:00 PM
Friday11:00 AM – 11:00 PM
Saturday11:00 AM – 11:00 PM
Sunday4:00 PM – 10:00 PM
Address
Grecco's Pizza
519 Lincoln Avenue
Bedford, IN 47421

Corner of O Street and Lincoln Ave.
The pizza-slice shaped building. You'll know it.

Get Directions

Ready to order?
We're ready.

Call us and we'll take care of the rest. Delivery to Bedford and Oolitic. Carryout always ready.

(812) 279-9791
or
Order on Grubhub →